Blog·27 October 2026·5 min read
Mastering Feedback: How to Ask for the Right Revision
For artists, producers and labels reviewing a master: how to write mastering feedback that is clear, specific and usable within your two included revisions.
Good mastering feedback is short, specific and tied to a moment in the song: which track, where in it, what you hear, and what you would like to hear instead. That is most of it. The rest of this article is about getting there, because the first listen to a master is rarely a calm one. You know every inch of your record, and a change you did not expect can feel like someone touched your mix without asking.
Two revisions are included on every master, from the same mix. That is plenty when the notes are clear. It runs out quickly when they are vague, because each round goes into guessing what "make it pop" meant instead of fixing the thing that bothered you.
Listen Before You Write Anything
A master is usually louder than the mix you sent. Louder sounds better for the first few seconds, then it starts to tire you, so a first impression is not reliable in either direction. Turn the master down until it sits at the same perceived level as your mix, then switch between the two. Only then are you hearing the mastering and not the volume. I go through the ways to set this up in comparing masters before release.
Listen where you know the sound: the speakers or headphones you mixed on, then the car, then a phone, then whatever your audience will actually use. Play the whole track, and if it is an EP or album, play the tracks in order. Write nothing during the first pass. Just listen to the record as a record, the way someone pressing play for the first time would. Your notes start on the second pass, with the mix ready to compare.
Describe What You Hear, With a Place in the Song
The most useful note names a track, a timestamp, an instrument and a direction. Here is what that looks like in practice:
- Track 3, 1:42: the snare gets smaller when the chorus comes in. In the mix it stays in front.
- Track 1, intro: the bass feels lighter in the low end than in my mix on the same speakers. Is that intended?
- Whole EP: tracks 4 and 5 feel a little brighter than the first three, the hi-hats stand out more.
Musician words are fine. Warm, boxy, thin, crowded, hard, soft, wide: I know what you mean when you point me to the moment. What does not help is a note with no place attached, like "needs more energy" across a whole album. And the most valuable note of all is anything that moved away from your mix. The goal isn't to change your mix, it's to make it the same, only better. If something you loved in the mix is gone, tell me exactly where you miss it.
Separate Mastering Notes From Mix Notes
Some notes are not mastering notes, and it saves a round to spot them early. A vocal that sits too low in one chorus, a reverb tail that is too long, one snare hit that is louder than the others: in a stereo master, lifting one element lifts everything that shares its range. If your note is about the balance of a single instrument in a single section, it is probably a mix note. If that kind of control matters for your record, stereo versus stem mastering is worth a read before the next release.
Going back to the mix is a perfectly good decision. Just know that revisions work from the same mix, and a new mix is a new master. It is better to decide which one you need before you send notes, so a revision round is not spent on something only the mix can solve.
Gather Every Voice Before You Send
For labels, A&R people and producers, this is the step that matters most. When the artist asks for more low end and the A&R asks for a tighter low end in separate emails, the two notes cancel each other and a revision goes nowhere. Listen separately, then agree among yourselves, then send one document from one person. If there is a record you all point to when you describe the sound you want, add it, and read reference tracks for more focused mastering first so the reference does the job you expect.
Put everything in one message: every track, numbered in the order of the release, each note with its timestamp. Include what you like, too. A line such as "track 2 is exactly right, do not touch it" is as useful to me as any correction, because it keeps the good parts from drifting while the others move.
How We Use the Two Revisions
When your notes arrive, I listen at each spot you marked, with your mix next to the master. If a note could go two ways, I ask before I touch anything, and we talk it through directly, you and me. Then the revision comes back with a short note on what was changed and where, so you know exactly what to listen for.
The first revision usually carries the bigger moves. The second is for fine tuning, and the moves get small. If you find yourself on the third listen of the day arguing with the same chorus, stop and come back with rested ears. Sometimes the note still stands, and then it goes in. Sometimes the master was fine and the ear was tired.
A master is finished when you play it next to your mix and hear the same record, with more of what was already there. The clearest notes are rarely long. They name a place, a sound and a direction, and they trust that the record you know is in there to be found.
Tell me about your record. One fixed price within one business day. Ask for a quote