Blog·10 November 2026·5 min read
What to Tell Your Mastering Engineer With Your Mixes
For artists, producers and labels sending an EP or album: what to tell your mastering engineer with the mixes, and what to leave out of the note.
What to tell your mastering engineer fits on one page, and that page shapes the master more than most people expect. The mix carries the music. The note carries your intent. When the note is clear, the first master already aims at the record you hear in your head, and the revisions go to detail instead of direction.
This matters most when the engineer works remotely and you are not in the room. You can't lean over and say "a bit less there." So the note does that job before the first listen. Below is what I find useful to read, in the order it helps, and what you can safely leave out.
Start With the Record, Not the Settings
Begin with a few plain sentences about what the record is meant to feel like. A dark, close hip-hop EP is a different job from a bright, open indie album, even if both mixes measure the same. Say where people will mostly hear it: club systems, headphones on a commute, a living room hi-fi, a jazz club's merch table on vinyl. Say what the record sits next to in your world, and who it is for.
Then say what you love about the mix. This is the most important line in the note, and it is the one people most often skip. If the snare took you three weeks, if the bass and kick finally lock, if the vocal sits exactly where you wanted it, write it down. Those are the things you would take personally if they moved, and a mastering engineer needs to know where the untouchable parts are before touching anything.
Name the Problems You Already Hear
You know your record better than anyone. If something has bothered you since the mix was printed, say so, with the song and a timestamp. "Track 3, the vocal gets a little sharp in the second chorus around 2:10" is worth more than any general request. "The low end feels heavier on track 5 than the rest" tells me where to listen first across an EP or album.
Just as useful: tell me what sounds like a problem but isn't. Tape hiss in an intro, a distorted bass on purpose, room noise between tunes on a live jazz date, a lo-fi drum loop that is meant to sound worn. Without a word from you, any of these can read as a fault to fix. With one line, they stay exactly as you made them.
Keep it to what you actually hear. If you are not sure whether something is a problem, say that too. "I can't decide if the hi-hats are too bright" is an honest, useful sentence, and it gives us something specific to talk through.
References, Loudness and Formats
One or two reference tracks help, as long as you say what you want from each one. "The weight of the low end on this song" or "how open the vocal sounds on that one" points to a quality, not a copy. I wrote more about choosing them in reference tracks for more focused mastering. A list of ten references with no notes tends to pull in ten directions.
On loudness, describe the feeling rather than a number, unless you know exactly why you need that number. "As dense as the rest of the scene" or "keep the dynamics, this is a quiet record" is a clear brief. Then list every format the release needs: streaming files, a vinyl master, a DDP for CD, clean or instrumental versions. Knowing this up front changes decisions from the first track, especially for vinyl, so it belongs in the note, not in a message two weeks later.
For an EP or Album: Order, Gaps and Names
If the record is more than one song, send the final track order, even if you think it might still move. Say which songs run into each other, where you want silence and roughly how much, and where a fade should land. If two tracks are meant as a pair, tell me. If you are still deciding the order, how to sequence album tracks that hold together is a good place to start before you send anything.
Write the song titles exactly as they will be released, with the spelling, capitals and featured artists the label will use. For a CD, add any codes the label has already assigned. Then name one person who signs off on the master. When an artist, a producer and an A&R all send notes, the record goes better if one voice gathers them first.
What You Can Leave Out
You don't need to describe your mix bus, your plugins or how you got there. You also don't need to write technical instructions like a cut at a certain frequency. Describe the sound instead: "the guitars feel a little boxy", "the cymbals tire my ears after a few songs". That leaves room to find the right fix, which may be in a different place from where you'd expect.
When your mixes arrive, the note is the first thing I read, and it is what we talk it through from. Each mix goes through one analog chain: tubes, transformers, tape character. The goal isn't to change your mix, it's to make it the same, only better. Your note is how I know what "the same" means for this particular record. Two revisions are included on every master, from the same mix, and a good note means those revisions can go to small things. When you send them, how to ask for the right revision follows the same idea: say what you hear, where, and what you want to feel instead.
A short, honest note will do more for your master than a long, cautious one. Say what the record is, what you love, what bothers you and what it has to become. The rest is listening, and that part goes better when we both know what we are listening for.
Tell me about your record. One fixed price within one business day. Ask for a quote